Showing posts with label general-evolution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label general-evolution. Show all posts

February 15, 2022

Gyrification of the Tree of Mammals

For this year's Darwin Day post, I will be reviewing the evolutionary origins and developmental emergence of gyrification of the Mammalian brain. Gyrification occurs when the neocortex, or six layered cortex on the dorsal surface of Mammalian brains, exhibits wrinkles and folds rather than a smooth surface (lissencephaly). Gyrification is measured using the gyrification index (or GI). GI can range from 5.6 in Pilot whales (Globicephala) to 3.8 in Elephants (Loxodonta) and 2.6 in Humans (Homo) [1]. A more extensive phylogenetic analysis (Figure 1) shows the evolutionary trajectory for this in Hominids, and a highly gyrified brain is associated with other traits that emerge as early as the divergence of Primates. 


Figure 1. A phylogeny of primate brain evolution (with Mammalian outgroups), with a focus on the origin of traits found in the human brain. COURTESY [2].

The evolutionary origins of gyrification may either be mono- or polyphyletic, as different genes have been identified as potential associated factors. Gyrification might also be a product of convergent evolution, as this trait may simply be a by-product of larger neocortical sheets. Steidter [3] points out that gyrification may simply be due to physical constraints related to fitting a vastly enlarged cortical sheet into a skull scaled to an organism's body size. 

Figure 2. Allometric scaling across select Mammalian brain, showing an increase in gyrification for larger brains. COURTESY [4].

In Figure 2, we see that in general larger brains also have a larger GI value. The curvilinear relationship shown in the figure is known as an allometric scaling. Allometry [5] is a convenient way to quantitatively assess relative growth across different species, and the resulting regression parameters are suggestive of underlying mechanisms that control and predict growth across evolution.

In this case, the allometric relationship is brain size versus tangential expansion. Tangential matter is expansion of gray matter relative to the constraints of white matter, or a grey-to-white matter proportion [4]. As the amount of gray matter increases, brain size also tends to increase, and so does the GI value. However, the proportion of gray to white matter saturates, while brain sizes continue to expand along with increasing GI values. 




Figure 3. Simulating gyrification as a by-product of physical processes. 3-D printed models based on MRI data for brains from different stages of development. COURTESY [6].

Genetic analyses implicate the role of specific genes in controlling brain volume, which then sets the stage for gyrification [7]. Developmental mutations in the human genetic loci collectively known as MCPH 1-18 [8] lead to a condition called microcephaly, where the mature microcephalic brain remains small and lacks gyrification. In a study of 34 species [9], the largest source of explained variance between species can be explained by random Brownian motion. Furthermore, the data within the order Primates shows that fold wavelength is stable (~12mm) despite a 20-fold difference in volume [9]. 

As an alternative hypothesis to evolutionary origins, gyrification can result from various physical processes in developmental morphogenesis (Figure 3). The gyrification process consists of gyral (ridge-like) and sulcal (groove-like) convolutions. In the earliest stages of development, no gyrification is expressed in the phenotype. However, as the neocortex grows faster relative to the rest of the brain, a mechanical instability results that leads to buckling [6]. Buckling thus creates gyrification, although the consistency of their localization and timing in development suggests underlying cellular and molecular mechanisms. Demonstration of biophysical mechanisms does not preclude a phylogenetic explanation, however. As we will see later on, surface physics relies upon the presence of certain cell types and growth conditions.


Figure 4. An overview of the evolution of development (Evo-Devo) of gyrification. Gyrification and lissencephaly occur through mechanisms that affect changes in brain size and GI relative to the last common ancestor (in this figure, transitional form). COURTESY [10].

There are also several cellular and molecular factors that contribute to neocortical growth, and thus towards gyrification. In Figure 4, we see four archetypes that result from increases and decreases of brain size coupled with increases and decreases of GI. For example, increases in basal radial ganglion (bRG) precursor cells and transit-amplifying progenitor cells (TAPs) contribute to increases of both brain size and GI [10]. Decreases in brain size and GI are controlled by changes in cell cycle timing and associated heterochronic changes. Heterochrony has to do with the timing of the rate and termination of growth in development and is but one factor that suggests lissencephaly is actually the derived condition. Thus, smooth brains would be an evolutionary reversal from the ancestral gyrified state that occurred multiple times across the tree of Mammals. 

Once again, an evolutionary conundrum. Happy evolutioning!

NOTES:

[1] Johnson, S. Number and Complexity of Cortical Gyrii. Center for Academic Research and Training in Anthropogeny. La Jolla, CA. Accessed: February 13, 2022. 

[2] Franchini, L.F. (2021). Genetic Mechanisms Underlying Cortical Evolution in Mammals. Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology, 9, 591017.

[3] Striedter, G. (2005). Principles of brain evolution. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA.

[4] Tallinen, T., Chung, J.Y. , Biggins, J.S., and Mahadevan, L. (2014). Gyrification from constrained cortical expansion. PNAS, 111(35), 12667-12672.

[5] Shingleton, A. (2010) Allometry: The Study of Biological Scaling. Nature Education Knowledge, 3(10), 2.

[6] Tallinen, T., Chung, J.Y., Rousseau, F., Girard, N., Lefevre, J., and Mahadevan, L. (2016). On the growth and form of cortical convolutions. Nature Physics, 12, 588–593.

[7] Zilles, K., Palomero-Gallagher, N., and Amunts, K. (2013). Development of cortical folding during evolution and ontogeny. Trends in Neurosciences, 36(5), 275-284. 

[8] Jayaraman, D., Bae, B-I., and Walsh, C.A. (2018). The Genetics of Primary Microcephaly. Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics, 19, 177-200.

[9] Heuer, K., Gulban, O.F., Bazin, P-L., Osoianu, A., Valabregue, R., Santin, M., Herbin, M., and Toro, R. (2019). Evolution of neocortical folding: A phylogenetic comparative analysis of MRI from 34 primate species. Cortex, 118, 275-291.

[10] Kelava, I., Lewitus, E., and Huttner, W.B. (2013). The secondary loss of gyrencephaly as an example of evolutionary phenotypical reversal. Frontiers in Neuroanatomy, 7, 16.


February 12, 2020

Sperry, Darwin, and the Evolution of Reference Frames

It's all about deforming the phenotype. COURTESY: DiPaola, Evolving Darwin's Gaze (click to enlarge).

For this year's Darwin Day (February 12), I will be discussing a classic Neuroscience experiment by Roger Sperry [1]. This was discussed recently on Twitter (Figures 1 and 3), along with a movie (Movie 1) that demonstrates the behavioral effect of this manipulation. In the movie, we can see before and after behaviors with respect to prey capture. Before the manipulation, the frog seamlessly captures flies with a flick of the tongue. Afterward, the frog flicks in precisely the opposite direction of the fly. What is the biology behind this manipulation, and why does the manipulation produce seemingly maladaptive behavior?  

Figure 1. Tweet on Sperry's eye rotation experiment and chemosensory hypothesis (click to enlarge). 

Movie 1. Video demonstration of Sperry's eye rotation experiment (click to enlarge). 

In conducting this experiment, a frog's eyes are surgically rotated 180 degrees about each socket (see Figure 2). Due to this treatment, the normal course of axonogenesis between the eyeball and the tectum (part of the frog brain) is distorted [2]. As a result, the connections are shifted and the visual information is mapped to different regions of the tectum. The tectum serves as a visuospatial map of the environment, and maps visual stimuli to a reference frame used to generate motor behavior. As the reference frame is than systematically rotates, so is the frog's movement behavior. Thus, our manipulated frog produces a tongue flick that is 180 degrees in the opposite direction of the prey it is trying to capture. 



Figure 2. Cartoon demonstrating chemosensory hypothesis and behavioral effects of eye rotation experiment (click to enlarge). 

What is known as the chemosensory hypothesis (see Figure 2) also provided support for another concept, that of experience-dependent plasticity. The second tweet (below) discusses how this concept explains (and does not explain) what we see in the frog tectum and its modified behavior.

Figure 3. Part of response to tweet in Figure 1, with an assessment of the functional consequences (click to enlarge). 

Roger Sperry is also known for another set of experiments conducted a few years later [3] that asked whether neuroplasticity was a real phenomenon (as opposed to an epiphenomenon). This was done by either abnormally innervating muscle or placing end-effectors (limbs) in maladaptive locations on the body. If the organism could overcome these changes, such changes could be overcome via adaptation. As in the case of the eye rotation experiment, motor patterns are not plastic, even when neuronal connections are non-specific. This is why the eye rotated frog cannot adjust its behavior to adaptation in the spatial representation of visual input. 


Figure 4. A demonstration of conduction delay in the quadruped hindlimb in relation to multiple components of the sensorimotor loop. COURTESY: Figure 1 in [7] (click to enlarge).

So what does this have to do with evolution by natural selection [4]? It turns out that there are scaling laws that govern the coordination of the nervous system and phenotype as they both emerge in development [5]. Specifically, there are characteristically proportional relationships between motor neuron innervation and target tissue size in different parts of the organism [5, Note 1]. This developmental relationship (which holds true across related species) leads to interesting functional consequences. More et.al [6] suggests a trade-off in sensorimotor systems between responsiveness (temporal respond to stimuli) and resolution (sensory discrimination translated into muscle force production) results from size variation across phylogeny. 

Figure 5. Scaling of various sources of delay across species. Scaling comparison is in terms of mass (kg) versus delay (ms). COURTESY: Figure 2 in [7] (click to enlarge).

This relationship between size and a responsiveness-resolution trade-off also affects behavior. More and Donelan [7] show that conduction delay (an indicator of reaction time) also scales with variation in organismal size (Figure 4). The delay in force production (behavioral output) can be explained mostly in terms of nerve conduction delay rather than a delay in the sensory or synaptic components of the sensorimotor loop (Figure 5). This suggests a fundamental constraint on motor behavior that is independent of sensory inputs or their neural representation. But notice what is said about frog tectum in Figure 3: while eye saccades and tongue movement that produce the movement itself are not controlled by the tectum, a triggering threshold results from the active representation of visual information. 

Through the efficiency of population coding [8], this representation determines the timing of movement execution, which occurs in spatial context along with an appropriate amount of force. Perhaps the rotated eye manipulation (and associated phenomena like the prism experiment) presents an interesting exception to the responsiveness/resolution trade-off. Perhaps an intervening variable, representational alignment, also affects the linearity of the primary trade-off for specific movement behaviors. Across different species with common ancestry [9], this could become quite variable, and even provide an evolutionary-based account of neural plasticity.


NOTES:
[1] Sperry, R.W. (1943). Effect of 180 Degree Rotation of the Retinal Field on Visuomotor Coordination. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 92(3), 263–279.

[2] the reference to chemoaffinity in the first tweet refers to the process of axons finding their way to a target tissue. This is the basis for Sperry's "chemoaffinity hypothesis". Please see: Meyer, R.L. (1998). Roger Sperry and his chemoaffinity hypothesis. Neuropsychologia, 36 (10), 957–980.

[3] Sperry, R.W. (1945). The Problem of Central Nervous Reorganization After Nerve Regeneration and Muscle Transposition. Quarterly Review of Biology, 20(4), 311-369.

[4] For more on this topic, please see the following Synthetic Daisies posts:




[5] Striedter, G.F. (2004). Principles of Brain Evolution. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.

[6] More, H.L., Hutchinson, J.R., Collins, D.F., Weber, D.J., Aung, S.K.H., and Donelan, J.M. (2010). Scaling of sensorimotor control in terrestrial mammals. Royal Society of London B, 277(1700), 3563-3568.

[7] More, H.L. and Donelan, J.M. (2018). Scaling of sensorimotor delays in terrestrial mammals. Royal Society of London B, 285(1855), 20180613.

[8] Shamir, M. (2014). Emerging principles of population coding: in search for the neural code. Current Opinion in Neurobiology, 25, 140-148 AND Pouget, A., Dayan, P., & Zemel, R. (2000). Information processing with population codes. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 1, 125–132.

[9] Quian Quiroga, R. (2019). Neural representations across species. Science, 363(6434), 1388-1389.

February 16, 2017

A Peripheral Darwin Day post, but Centrality in his Collaboration Graph

Happy Darwin Day-ish! COURTESY: Kapil Bhagat

Having not decided on what to post for Darwin Day 2017 in advance (and thus being late to the party with my annual post), I will be taking a rather circular approach to this post. I recently read a blog post on a TEDMED talk by Artem Kazneechev [1] on how theorists offer opportunities for collaboration across multiple research domains and existing research communities. The most extreme case is that of Paul Erdos, for whom the term "Erdos number" was coined [2]. The Erdos number defines a degree of association on a collaboration graph between a given author and Erdos as defined through co-authorship [3]. The role of theorists in such collaboration graphs is intriguing, and involves their role as hubs (highly-connected nodes) in a scale-free network topology [4]. In terms of the scientific community, such hubs often serve as connectors between disciplinary groups and sub-communities.

Darwin at the center (a hub with a high degree of centrality) of a hypothetical collaboration graph. Image is actually of an evolutionary amplifier, a computational structure from Evolutionary Graph Theory. Image of Darwin is from Dinochick's blog.

As Kazneechev [1] points out, sometimes one need not be as prolific as Paul Erdos to serve as a connector. Henri Poincare was a bit less prolific, and certainly did not live out of a suitcase, but serves as a scientific connector nonetheless. In fact, all theorists are at an advantage in this regard. This makes me wonder what a collaboration graph centered on Charles Darwin would look like. While I do not have the neccessary data, I would imagine it would quite different from Erdos' graph. This is because Darwin (as far as I know) did not publish collaborative papers. However, a citation network [5] in which documents rather than scientists serve as the nodes might better capture Darwin's role as an influencer, and thus partially recapitulate the topology of an Erdos-based collaboration graph.

Lately, I have been doing some unfocused research on polymathy [6]. One of the things that has fascinated me is the distinction between "domain-specific" knowledge and "general" knowledge, particularly as it relates to specialization. One criticism of modern science is that it suffers from hyper-specialization. The trend towards hyper-specialization has been constant over historical time, and now contrasts sharply with the scientists of the 16th and 17th century. This trend has been countered in a number of ways, particularly through interdisciplinary initiatives. Yet all too often, interdisciplinarity is reduced to groups of specialists gathered in the same room talking past one another.

A "T" shape skillset in terms of employment skills and educating talent. COURTESY: T-Summit 2014.

I am interested in taking a landscape model approach to modeling polymathy as a function of expertise and semantic specialization. In getting there, we have to understand the relationships (various dimensions) of specialization and generalized knowledge. According to the education and tech literature, the traditional polymath can be modeled as a "T". In fact, the T-shaped skillset is back in vogue in some fields (e.g. design, project management). It is somewhat difficult to make the leap from abstract skills to specific facts and other knowledge that facilitates (or constrains) scientific collaboration. 


Components of the "I" shape in terms of academic influence and expertise. More information on this work to come.

To help this along, I have worked out an ontological and semantic model of scientific expertise. In the figure above, I show the bivariate model as a shape representing the relative "depth and "breadth" of a particular style of scientific practice. While there are "Is" (specialists) and "Ts" (generalists with a single specialty), there are also "combs" (generalists with multiple specialties) and "dashes" (pure generalists). "Combs" are most analogous to the traditional polymath, but it is interesting to ask where Charles Darwin (and other theorists) would fit into this type of scheme. 


While Darwin has shaped the thinking of many scholars in multiple fields (both traditional and upstart) over the past 150 years, he was also influenced by a variety of thinkers. Even more than a scientific specialist, the essence of theorists can be captured by multiple-input, multiple-output (MIMO) graphs of major ideas. This can extend even beyond the lifetime of the scientist. The following graphical example of influencers and the influenced (inputs and outputs) is from Semantic Scholar, and shows Charles Darwin's position in a semi-directed citation network within the Computer Science community.

Charles Darwin's academic influence as MIMO graph. See profile for details on how graph is computed.


NOTES:
[1] Kazneechev, A. (2012). Theorists as Connectors: from Poincare to mathematical medicine. Theory, Evolution, and Games Group blog, November 4.

[2] Newman, M.E.J. (2004). Who Is the Best Connected Scientist? A Study of Scientific Coauthorship Networks. Lecture Notes in Physics, 650, 337–370.

[3] Alicea, B. (2011). Academic Connectivity and the Future of Scientific Ideas. Synthetic Daisies blog, September 9.

[4] Newman, M.E.J. (2001). The structure of scientific collaboration networks. PNAS, 98(2), 404-409.

[5] More information about citation networks and their usefulness to the practice of science can be found in: Editorial (2010). On citing well. Nature Chemical Biology, 6, 79.

[6] A few popular readings on polymathy: Arbesman, S. (2013). Let's Bring the Polymath -- and the Dabblers -- Back. Wired, December 13 AND Mazie, S. How to be a Polymath. Big Think blog.

March 13, 2016

New Paper on Experimental Evolution (with Nematodes!)


Here is a new paper from the bioRxiv on experimental evolution in Nematodes titled "Evolution in Eggs and Phases: experimental evolution of fecundity and reproductive timing in Caenorhabditis elegans". This represents work done during 2015 in Nathan Schroeder's laboratory at UIUC [1], and is published as part of the new Reproduction and Developmental Plasticity theme in the DevoWorm group (currently consisting of just myself). Here is the abstract:
To examine the role of natural selection on fecundity in a variety of Caenorhabditis elegans genetic backgrounds, we used an experimental evolution protocol to evolve 14 distinct genetic strains over 15-20 generations. Beginning with three founder worms for each strain, we were able to generate 790 distinct genealogies, which provided information on both the effects of natural selection and the evolvability of each strain. Among these genotypes are a wildtype (N2) and a collection of mutants with targeted mutations in the daf-c, daf-d, and AMPK pathways. The overarching goal of our analysis is two-fold: to observe differences in reproductive fitness and observe related changes in reproductive timing. This yields two outcomes. The first is that the majority of selective effects on fecundity occur during the first few generations of evolution, while the negative selection for reproductive timing occurs on longer timescales. The second finding reveals that positive selection on fecundity results in positive and negative selection on reproductive timing, both of which are strain-dependent. Using a derivative of population size per generation called the reproductive carry-over (RCO) measure, it is found that the fluctuation and shape of the probability distribution may be informative in terms of developmental selection. While these consist of general patterns that transcend mutations in a specific gene, changes in the RCO measure may nevertheless be products of selection. In conclusion, we discuss the broader implications of these findings, particularly in the context of genotype-fitness maps and the role of uncharacterized mutations in individual variation and evolvability.

 C. elegans adults, juveniles, and eggs in an unsynchronized culture. COURTESY: Bowerman Lab, University of Oregon.

The entire dataset (genealogies for fecundity and reproductive carry-over measurements) is publically available. Below is a heat map (Figure 6 in the paper) featuring the distribution of that measurement for 14 wildtype and mutant genotypes.

NOTES
[1] For related work, please see "An Experimental Evolution Approach to Understanding C. elegans Adaptability", Poster 766C at the 20th International C. elegans Meeting (2015), Los Angeles, CA.

February 12, 2016

Darwin Day, Past and Present

For this year's Darwin Day (his 207th posthumous birthday), we take a tour of Darwin Day features from both the past and present.

Panel discussion at the Darwin Centennial Celebration, University of Chicago circa 1959.

First stop: last year's Synthetic Daisies post for Darwin Day, featuring portraits of Charles Darwin throughout the course of his lifetime.

Second stop: 2009, and Nature's special issue for Darwin's 200th birthday, which includes many nice multimedia features.

Third stop: Google's Doodle from February 12, 2009 and  a Doodle-like short movie from 2014. Link to the Doodle design and animated movie can be found below. The movie is quite elaborate, as each letter making up "Google" are treated as terminal taxa in a prototypical tree of life.


Darwin Day Google Doodle from 2014. COURTESY: Vimeo and Devone Paul

Final stop: The Selfish Gene. This year's Darwin Day roughly coincides with the 40th anniversary of "The Selfish Gene" by Richard Dawkins. This work established the gene as the fundamental unit of natural selection, and provided a strong defense of Darwinian ideas. Enjoy these readings by John Brockman ("About Richard Dawkins") and Matt Ridley ("In Retrospect: The Selfish Gene").



Happy Darwin Day!

June 30, 2015

Posters at the International C. elegans Meeting

UCLA and Los Angeles. COURTESY: UCLA Department of Physiology.

I just returned from the International C. elegans Meeting in Los Angeles (being hosted on the UCLA campus). There are posters, talks, workshops, and much fun to be had. I will give a more detailed discussion of some of the sessions in a future post.

Some people (not me) took turns wearing the "worm suit".

There were several days of talks and posters, plus the famous C. elegans art and variety shows. Talks ranged from Physiology to Evolution and Development. The worm art show is somewhat unique to the conference, The OpenWorm group was able to meet up and discuss research strategies. 


There was also a worm art show. Here are some of the entries. 

Aside form partaking in the intellectual and social festivities, I also presented two posters on Saturday night. One was in the area of experimental evolution, and the other on the DevoWorm project.

Sample of the Experimental Evolution poster. Full poster can be viewed/downloaded here.

Sample of the DevoWorm poster. Full poster can be viewed/downloaded here.

My week was not all worm biology. I also sampled some botany, courtesy of the Mildred Mathias Botanical Garden, UCLA.






March 9, 2015

Review of "Arrival of the Fittest"

"Arrival of the Fittest" is the latest book by Andreas Wagner, a professor at the University of Zurich in Switzerland. The book [1] tackles a subtly complicated topic: the evolution and evolvability of innovations using a biochemical and computational perspective. For the most part, Wagner succeeds at presenting an elegant case for how the ability to naturally evolve innovations lies at the heart of the evolutionary process. To get there, however, Wagner must introduce us to a number of semi-obscure concepts (at least to the layman). The book can be summarized in four parts: survival of the most novel (I), the concept of innovability (II), the safe and the risky (III), and multiple origins, multiple solutions (IV). I will give a technical review of the book by highlighting these four interrelated themes.



I. Survival of the most novel.
To understand the propagation of innovative solutions throughout the tree of life, it is important to understand the difference between the force of evolution versus the role of selection. Wagner proposes that, rather than creating innovations, the role of natural selection is to preserve them. Innovations themselves are the result mutation, recombination and historical contingencies. The first two mechanisms are capable of randomly generating either very simple innovations or the components of more complex innovations. But to achieve the "tinkering" that seems to be prevalent in complex genetic pathways and phenotypes, we need to have standard meta-components that can lock in previous changes. This allows for the limited exploration of a fitness space without incurring the cost of losing previous advances.


Wagner teases historical contingencies this into two classes: building blocks and standards. In the case of building blocks, the working components that result from previous innovation are modularized into larger units. This allows for increasing complexity to be had from a stochastic process (evolution) as well as accelerating the process of finding and retaining novelties (innovation). The coordination of building blocks often leads to standards, which are much more flexible than hyper-specialized systems but are much more able to deal with hyper-complexity.

Building blocks assembled into a complex structure.

Wagner illustrates this by comparing metabolic engines (a high-tolerance biological engine) with the internal combustion engine (a high-precision mechanical innovation). While metabolic engines can use an interchangeable set of fuels and reactants, internal combustion engines require specific specifications to operate. While one might argue that this implies mechanical engines will be "optimized" and metabolic engines will be made "good enough", this is indeed the point. Rather than survival of the fittest, we observe a survival of the fit enough, with selection acting strongest on functional novelties that augment fitness.

A high-tolerance but highly-specific engine (internal combustion) type.

II. Concept of innovability.
In the case of complex metabolic networks, the basic function has not changed throughout evolutionary history. What has changed is the number of reactions, which scales with evolutionary complexity. This scaling requires very general standards. But to make these standards interoperable across divergent evolution, a diversity of building blocks regulatory mechanisms are also required. This leads us to a set of principles which can explain general trends in innovation rather than on a case-by-case basis. Another such principle involves the number of parts and identity of a specific innovation. The number of interacting parts and their configuration provides a means to compare specific innovations in a hypothetical manner. Wagner proposes that this be done using a high-dimensional structure such as a hypercube [2] or a neutral network [3].

In a hypercube representation, each node represents a specific genotype, while the edges represent pathways (or the accumulation of mutations) between genotypes. In short, the shortest paths are the most probable. In a highly-connected space, a long distance can be traveled across the space in a short number of mutations (or edges).

III. The safe and the risky.
How can the structure of a biological system make things safe for innovation? Certainly, blindly changing key components of a metabolic network or developmental scaffolding without regard for essential function can result in lethality. The presence of the building blocks and standards principles provides a failsafe means to tinker or change without lethal disruption. But there are two other principles at work: redundancy and connectivity. These principles are arguably more important in acting as gatekeepers for the fitness benefits reaped by innovations.

A machine finding its way through a maze. One way to search for novel solutions in a de novo fashion.

Redundancy involves the presence of multiple parts that play a similar or interchangeable role in the functioning of a system. For example, both genetic and metabolic networks can be robust to the removal of single components. When components get removed without having a consequence on function [4], we can say that such a component is redundant. Gene duplications can play a similar role: single copies can be knocked out without a large detriment to fitness. Related to redundant function is, of course, robustness. Robustness can be thought of as how much redundancy exists in a specific system. Wagner gives the example of phenocopying as a way in which developmental robustness can lead to redundant phenotypic configurations.

Connectivity is a less appreciated aspect of evolution. Yet in terms of functional and conceptual unity, connectivity is an essential component of evolving systems that produce innovation. Three aspects of connectivity are most important here: interaction type, density, and connection order. There are a number of interaction types in biological networks that can give rise to innovation. For example, we can look to genetic networks (interaction between genes), breeding networks (interactions between conspecifics), or even the aforementioned neutral networks (interactions between evolutionary configurations) for ways in which connectivity can yield pathways that lead to innovations of high fitness.

An example of a genetic (gene interaction) network. Sometimes this approach is called "hairball science". COURTESY: Figure 1 in [5].

Network density (or the number of interconnections between nodes) allows for a greater number of potential innovative solutions to be explored in a shorter number of steps. This can increase the number of potential solutions, which can be reached in a shorter number of evolutionary steps and/or time (depending on your perspective). In the neutral network, a number of "safe" pathways of equivalent fitness are created for the innovating pathway or organism to explore. While the network density is important in facilitating innovation, the connection order of the network is also important. In networks with a short connection order (e.g. small-world networks), even random paths through the network can yield large-scale, non-deleterious change.

An example of constituent genotypes in a neutral network with reference to robustness. COURTESY: Ricardo Azevedo, Wikipedia.

IV. Multiple origins, multiple solutions.
The final point of Wagner's book is to remind us that innovations can be achieved through multiple unique solutions, and that existing innovations may have had multiple origin points. While evolution also has no unique solution, innovation is particularly subject to parallel evolution. Since this book does not shy away from computational representations, Wagner applies the idea of evolution strategies [6] to illustrate how innovations can be modeled as a five-part process. Specifically, innovation involves trial-and-error, population-based exploration, solutions with multiple origins, a combinatorial structure, and a stochastic process with a mutation-selection structure. While these factors also define the evolutionary process, we might say that innovation is inseparable from evolution by natural selection. Thinking more broadly and considering social systems, cultural innovation might also be best characterized as an evolutionary process. Wagner's approach to innovation as evolvability is a useful and accessible introduction to the topic, and places this new set of concepts and terminology directly into the context of evolution by natural selection.

NOTES:
[1] For other, briefer reviews, please see: Hoppe, R.B.   Andreas Wagner: Arrival of the Fittest: Solving Evolution’s Greatest Puzzle. Panda's Thumb blog, November 4 (2014) AND Pagel, M.   The Neighborly Nature of Evolution. Nature, 514, 34 (2014).

[2] For an example, please see: Gavrilets, S. and Gravner, J.   Percolation on the Fitness Hypercube and the Evolution of Reproductive Isolation. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 184(1), 51–64 (1997).

[3] For an example, please see: Wagner, A.   Robustness and Evolvability in Living Systems. Princeton University Press (2005).

[4] Li, J., Yuan, Z., and Zhang, Z.   The Cellular Robustness by Genetic Redundancy in Budding Yeast. PLoS Genetics, 6(11), e1001187 (2010).

[5] Magtanong, L. et.al   Dosage suppression genetic interaction networks enhance functional wiring diagrams of the cell. Nature Biotechnology, 29, 505-511 (2011).

[6] Evolution strategies assumes that evolution is an optimizing process that results from the iterative application of a mutation-selection model. For more, please see: Schwefel, H-P.   Numerical optimazaion of computer models. Wiley Press, Chichester (1981) AND Beyer, H-G. and Schwefel, H-P.   Evolution Strategies: A Comprehensive Introduction. Journal of Natural Computing, 1(1), 3–52 (2002).

February 12, 2015

Darwin Day Short

He did it all for the finches (and their beaks).

Here's wishing everyone a Happy Darwin Day for 2015 (Darwin's 206th posthumous birthday)! Here is a short pictoral profile. And check out the hashtag #darwinday on Tumblr for more features and events. And, as a bonus, here is a new paper in Nature [1] that uses genome resequencing to better understand the adaptive variation in finch beaks.

Young Darwin

Middle-aged Darwin

Old Man Darwin

NOTES:
[1] Lamichhaney, S.     Evolution of Darwin’s finches and their beaks revealed by genome sequencing. Nature, doi:10.1038/nature14181 (2015).


Printfriendly