Showing posts with label University-of-Florida. Show all posts
Showing posts with label University-of-Florida. Show all posts

August 27, 2013

Evolutionary Models from the Reading Queue

As my reading queue is always bigger than my attentional throughput, I have decided that when I hit upon a theme, I will blog about the papers involved. In this post, recent papers from PLoS Computational Biology and PLoS One illustrate three instances of evolutionary modeling, which I will provide a guided tour of for a general audience.

What is an evolutionary model? Since evolution is hard to observe in most cases, we require models to fully appreciate what it means to evolve. While we could merely observe extant organisms and ruminate on the adaptive significance of specific traits, a more complete picture can be gathered from fossils [1] and comparative anatomy. Yet these are static evolutionary models -- static in the sense that all change (e.g. dynamics) is inferred from the observed data.

Can we improve upon this? The evolutionary analysis of genomes and phylogenetic simulations are quasi-static models -- models that work with more information but still rely significantly on dynamic inference. Not that there's anything wrong with that. But we could also simulate the organisms and conditions under which evolution operates. This can provide us with general principles that can corroborate (or in some cases reinterpret) our inferential endeavors.


What is an evolutionary model? Here are some static evolutionary models (a.k.a. fossils). Pictures from the Florida Museum of Natural History (FLMNH) Hall of Fossils.

Using mathematical and computational techniques, models can be used to support hypotheses and ideas related to evolutionary acceleration, complexity, and tradeoffs. While the models may look nothing like the traditional forms of evidence, they may nevertheless provide insight into the fundamental mechanisms of evolution.

1) Evolutionary "acceleration": In "Epigenetic Feedback Regulation Accelerates Adaptation and Evolution" [2], the authors use simplified gene regulatory network models with epigenetic inputs to model a phenomenon called epigenetic feedback regulation (EFR). This is done by modeling three scenarios using differential equations: noise-driven adaptation with EFR, EFR without growth dependency, and EFR under evolution.

Gene expression dynamics as represented in [2]. A dynamic model, as opposed to a fossil.

In the first case (noise-driven adaptation with EFR), a property called growth is tied explicitly to gene expression patterns (a direct result of EFR). The population of networks initially exhibits itinerant growth dynamics (e.g. fast, then slow, then fast again). Over time, the population settles into a high growth regime.

When growth and expression patterns are decoupled (made independent of one another), active growth can be achieved without gene expression being distributed across too many attractor basins. Put another way, gene expression will tend to be more coherent and can be synchronized across the network.

Finally, in the case of EFR under evolution, populations of networks are evolved and compared with network that are generated randomly. Evolution allows a greater proportion of networks to exhibit a steady growth rate (Figure 1), which suggests that the effects of EFR seen in the non-evolutionary cases also play a role in evolution with natural selection.


Figure 1. Figure 6 from [2]. Green function represents the effects of evolution over randomly-assembled networks.


2) Evolutionary increases in complexity: In "The Minimal Complexity of Adapting Agents Increases with Fitness" [3], the authors use an animat (artificial life agent) brain to model the hypothesis that the complexity of a population increases over evolutionary time. This study is based on the premise that adaptation is a multivariate process which occurs at multiple time-scales. So during the course of evolution we should expect some traits in a lineage to evolve faster than others.

We should also expect a generalized increase in complexity, as this differential adaptation results in more moving parts (so to speak). In this case, the investigation is restricted to an animat population's neural complement (Figure 2, top), which is represented using twelve binary variables (similar in composition to phylogenetic character states). The animat population is evolved over 60,000 generation. The resulting complexity is evaluated statistically using mutual information and an integrated information measure (Figure 2, bottom) related to Giulio Tonini's Phi parameter.

Figure 2. Figures 2 (top) and 3 (bottom) from [3]. Animat architecture (top) and fitness measured against complexity (as characterized by mutual information) over evolutionary time (bottom).


3) Evolutionary tradeoffs: In "Evolutionary Tradeoffs between Economy and Effectiveness in Biological Homeostasis Systems" [4], a multi-task (e.g. Pareto) optimization approach is used to bridge the effectivity and economical aspects of an evolving physiological system. Effectivity refers to functional coherence during the performance of a task, while economy refers to doing things like repair or investment without incurring a high fitness cost.

For the uninitiated, Pareto optimality is a situation where the allocation of resources between the two tasks is a non-zero sum outcome. Assuming Pareto optimality is a possible condition, this leads to a set of best compromises between the two tasks (Figure 3). This has relevance to the function of homeostatic (e.g. regulatory) mechanisms, and potentially the evolvability and adaptability of these mechanisms.


Figure 3. Figure 4 form [4]. The relationship between effectiveness (a) and economy (b), expressed as points along a Pareto front (black function, c).


For the skeptics who don't see the relevance of these papers to evolutionary science, I should point out that these models are not intended to mimic real biology or actual organisms. In this sense, the models above might be viewed as useless curiosities. However, modeling is not about fully replicating biology. Rather, good models should approximate key parameters (e.g. those that explain the most variance) in a process.

Perhaps it is with irony the best biological models might actually be considered "false" models. The intentional use of false models [5] has a significant history in the modeling of biological complexity. These false models (according to [5] there are seven types) include those with the following attributes:

1) Models that have very local applicability. While they lack generalizability, they do describe local phenomena well. These type of models might be employed to understand unique phenomena. This type of model can also be contrasted with models that overly idealize nature (next point).

2) Models that are an idealization of nature. Neural Network models fall into this category. The only properties of the brain that matter are neurons, their connections, and a mechanism for excitability. Ignoring all other complexity in the brain still gives us a somewhat-useful model of cognition.

3) Models that are incomplete but causally relevant. If a tree falls in the woods because it has been struck by lightning and its innards consumed by termites, and if you only observe the tree falling down in a slight breeze, you would conclude that the slight breeze caused the tree to collapse. One causal factor (and in some cases an important one), but not the entire story [6].

4) Models that intentionally mis-describe interactions between variables (e.g. spurious context independence, reductionist bias). In the service of seeking causality, important (and often critical) interactions between variables are overlooked. In reductionist science, the focus on one or two variables (e.g. finding a gene responsible for x) in the face of great complexity is another version of this point. While these few variables may describe much of the variance, oftentimes they do not.

5) Models that are fundamentally wrong-headed descriptions of nature. This becomes an issue when models adopted for the first four points are greatly successful, and their adoption/use becomes self-perpetuating. Intuitive or naive models (e.g. models that sound consistent with intuition but are not supported by evidence) also fall into this category.

6) Models that are purely phenomenological in nature (e.g. genome annotation). While this type of model is useful for understanding the structure of a problem, it is hard to elucidate function using the same model. This is of course true when a model lacks predictive power. However, since our knowledge of most complex systems is incomplete, purely phenomenological models are in essence false (but often useful).

7) Models that fail to describe or predict the data correctly. The use of curve-fitting techniques and characteristic functions falls into this category. While characteristic functions are useful approximations of mean behavior, it does not describe the natural variation well. While much effort is put into outlier detection, less effort is put into understanding the relative significance of outlier data points.

In conclusion, these examples also reveal two things about evolutionary models:

* Any single model cannot be an all-purpose tool. As shown in the examples above, a single model might be very good at modeling a specific phenomenon (e.g. the relationship between gene regulation and adaptation), but not at all relevant to other aspects of evolution (e.g. evolutionary divergence).

* Dynamic models, like fossils (e.g static models), are incomplete. This does not imply a fault in one line of evidence or another. Rather, it is suggestive of their cooperative role in our understanding of evolutionary processes.

NOTES:

[1] For more information on how fossils can be used as evolutionary models, please see the GB3D Fossil Database.

[2] Furusawa, C. and Kaneko, K.   Epigenetic Feedback Regulation Accelerates Adaptation and Evolution. PLoS One, 8(5), e61251 (2013).

[3] Joshi, N.J., Tononi, G., and Koch, C.   The Minimal Complexity of Adapting Agents Increases with Fitness. PLoS Computational Biology, 9(7), e1003111 (2013).

[4] Szekely, P., Sheftel, H., Mayo, A., and Alon, U.   Evolutionary Tradeoffs between Economy and Effectiveness in Biological Homeostasis Systems. PLoS Computationakl Biology, 9(8), e1003163 (2013).

[5] Wimsatt, W.   False Models as a Means to Truer Theories. Chapter 2 in Nitecki, M.H. and Hoffman, A. Neutral Models in Biology. Oxford, New York (1987).

[6] Nielsen, M.   If correlation doesn't imply causation, then what does? Data-driven Intelligence (DDI) blog, January 23 (2012).

November 5, 2012

5 years or 20,000 visits, whichever comes first....

Five years ago next month, I founded Synthetic Daisies. The name [1] is based on a merger of my interest in artificial and synthetic life (Synthetic) with my interest in systems thinking (Daisies, based on the Daisyworld experiments of James Lovelock). And yet historically at least, the blog have covered much more. The first post was a review of the book “The Complementary Nature”, followed by two sets of posts: one post on non-optimality [2] and another on YouTube videos from the grand opening of Dickinson Hall at the University of Florida [3]. Since then, I have posted on a mix of biological, computational, and innovation-related topics (broadly construed). I try to keep it balanced between these three areas, with some pop culture and geeky technology fun thrown in.

Images from the first Synthetic Daisies posts (using current template). LEFT: Complementary Nature review, CENTER: non-optimality post, RIGHT: YouTube videos of the Dickinson Hall opening.

My blogging style has evolved since starting Synthetic Daisies. For one thing, I have optimized the template design and layout towards something that is attractive to look at as it is to read (not sure I have totally succeeded at this, but I’ve tried). I have also used a number of devices to convey what is sometimes highly complicated information to a general audience. One of these is a preponderance of diagrams and images. Another is a moving a lot of technical detail to footnotes. Being true to the interactive nature of a blog, I sometimes update posts with retrospective information (after the original event or thoughts that inspired the post). This is a good way to keep your posts from becoming "archival" (and perhaps even embarrassing) in feel after a few months or years.

After posting sporadically for the first three years, I made the commitment to keep up the frequency of new posts (at least one post every 1-2 weeks). If you are starting a blog, don’t be afraid to post a large number of posts without immediate readership or feedback. If it is good and you promote them, the traffic will follow. I must also say that blogging on a regular basis has improved my writing skills. Although it takes a lot of effort, I hope that people find this blog both useful and entertaining.

An example of the previous blog template (circa May 2012).

Not bad for the first 4.917 years. However, according to the blogspot.com analytics, it appears that I have reached 20,000 [4] views (this includes all posts and pages). Many of these views are due to a handful of posts, as the number of views per post follows a power-law distribution [5].  One thing that helped my blog along is participating in the Carnival of Evolution (CoE) [6]. Another helper in getting readership is thinking about innovative topics to cover (e.g. thinking outside the blog template, so to speak). I also publicize my posts on Facebook, Tumblr [7], and my research website where appropriate. Finally, I have integrated the blog with my research projects and teaching activities, which helps along the topical innovation.

Power-law-distribution [8] of views per post (left) and time-series of views for all time and by week (top right, subsample) and all-time (lower right).

The ten most viewed posts and their rates of accession (data collated on 11/5/2012).
Post Title
Views
Viewing Rate (per day)
2522
11.57
814
3.21
702
2
614
2.15
297
1.16
293
0.79
292
0.93
277
0.43
267
5.45
264
0.88
* = featured in an edition of CoE.

NOTES:

[1] See the explanation page for more information.

[2] This was a very rough idea at the time. It is also quite unconventional. In engineering and economics, there are whole subfields, library stacks, and conferences devoted the notion of “optimization”. However, in a number of fields (such as Molecular Biology, Evolutionary Ecology, and Cultural Anthropology), models of optimality do not explain the data well. I eventually worked this idea into an arXiv paper called “The ‘Machinery’ of Biocomplexity: understanding non-optimal architectures in biological systems”.

[3] Dickinson Hall was opened in the 1960s as the original home of the Florida Museum of Natural History (FLMNH). It is now used as a research facility and to house the collections not on exhibition.  Link to post.


[4] To be precise, probably sometime tomorrow. Most of these visits are legitimate (e.g. not spambots or other redundant counts). What people are getting out of each visit, however, is not known.

[5] Notably, the traffic with respect to time is bursty, especially on a day-to-day basis (as expected).

[6] I hosted CoE #46 with the theme of evolutionary trees (which has earned roughly 2500 views). See it here. I plan to host again next year. CoE is the longest-running blog carnival (which is a monthly review of the blogosphere for a certain topic). Thanks to The Genealogical World of Phylogenetic Networks for this analysis.


[7] I keep a Tumblr site (Tumbld Thoughts) for some of my shorter concepts, observations, and sets of hyperlinks. This “microblogging” platform is particularly good for this purpose. Analytics are currently being collected.

[8] Rank order distribution plotted on a log-log plot. The distribution of views per post follows a power-law distribution, assuming that all traffic flow to the site over time is a Poisson process.......you know, all the good stuff.......

December 31, 2008

Florida Museum of Natural History: prehistory on film.

This is really cool! Who says that YouTube is contributing to the downfall of civilization (I am not among those people, but whatever)? Have a look at these videos from the UF libraries archive. I used to work here as a Masters student:



This is the dedication of Dickinson Hall, which is now the "old" FLMNH (where they house most of the collections and scientific research today). By contrast, the "new" FLMNH (with the fully-functioning Butterfly rainforest) is out on Museum road near 34th Street (which is just off the lower left edge of the map shown below):


The whole buliding was designed to look (and apparently function, since it dosen't have freight elevators) like a Mayan pyramid nestled into the side of a hill. Notice how the front entrance appears tobe a single story while the plaza in back looks quite expansive with staircases and everything. In the background you can see Carrtram Hall (a portmanteau of Carr and Bartram Halls, home of the Zoology and Botany departments).

If you ever pass by (right on I-75) or visit Gainesville, FL, do yourself a favor and visit this museum. You'll learn a hell of a lot more than you will at Disney, and they have some pretty good collections, especially pertaining to Florida, Carribean, and South American biodiversity/cultural history.

More UF trivia as the opportunity presents itself......

Printfriendly