Showing posts with label life-history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label life-history. Show all posts

October 26, 2014

C. elegans as an Evolutionary Model

In the past year, I have been starting to use the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans (roundworm) as a model organism. Not only have I helped to establish the DevoWorm project, I am also starting to engage with C. elegans in a wet-lab setting. As a consequence, I am learning about multiple facets of C. elegans biology. C. elegans is a well-established model organism, having well-characterized neural and developmental systems. The nervous system contains just 302 cells, with a full accounting of the connectome (synaptic connections) [1]. The developmental system is also well-characterized, with a lineage tree [2] having been worked out for the entire organism. While a lineage tree relies upon deterministic mechanisms (and thus cannot be applied to organisms such as Mammals), it does provide us with a clear accounting of cell differentiation and organ formation during development. Thus, C. elegans is a tractable model for whole-organism investigations (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Anatomy of the adult hermaphrodite. COURTESY: WormAtlas.

But what about evolution? At first pass, it seems as though asking evolutionary questions is not a tractable feature of roundworm biology. Nevertheless, we can use this worm to answer several outstanding questions in evolution [4]. I will use information from a recent review by Jeremy Gray and Asher Cutter [5] to discuss these potential research advances (Figure 2). The actual future applications of C. elegans as an evolutionary model might turn out to investigate other issues. As it turns out, the roundworm provides a happy medium between more traditional models of experimental evolution (microbes) and complex organisms with long generation times (humans). While C. elegans have a relatively short generation time (~50 hours), they also have complex phenotypes with organs.

Figure 2. The life cycle and means of experimental manipulation for evolution experiments. COURTESY: Figure 1 in [5].

The most common means of experimental evolution proposed in [5] is the mutation accumulation (MA) approach. MA may also serve as a weak factor in determining life-history traits in a species [6]. In experimental evolution, the MA approach allows us to observe the role of mutational variation in evolution. One way to apply this method might be to manipulate a single gene (using directed mutagenesis, gene editing, or RNAi -- see Figure 2) and then place it in a genetic background. Rather than waiting for a series of mutations to emerge in a population, mutation is induced to maximize the variation upon which evolution can act upon [7].

Another means of experimental evolution discussed in [5] is co-evolution between worms and pathogens. This can done by culturing worms in ecological context over several generations. One prediction involves the evolution of tradeoffs observed in already co-evolved relationships such as C. elegans growth rate and pathogenic resistance [8]. A secondary means of understanding the ecology of evolution involves introducing environmental fragmentation through introducing spatial variation (physical barriers or agar gradients) on a culture dish. This can produce to genetic bottlenecks and other effects related to population structure and neutral processes.

A third strategy discussed in [5] involves examining different reproductive strategies and degrees of adaptability between species of Caenorhabditis. The latter topic might include a better understanding of how the degeneracy [9] of neuronal and genetic circuits that lead to observable behaviors and phenotypes evolves. Yet there is also great potential for C. elegans to be used as an eco-evo-devo [10] model which integrates to response of environmental stimuli by cell and molecular mechanisms of development over evolutionary time (Figure 3). While I do not have plans on establishing my own C. elegans experimental evolution program in the near future, stay tuned.

Figure 3. A fledgling eco-evo-devo approach to C. elegans.

NOTES:
[1] Jarrell, T.A., Wang, Y., Bloniarz, A.E., Brittin, C.A., Xu, M., Thomson, J.N., Albertson, D.G. Hall, D.H., and Emmons, S.W.   The Connectome of a Decision-Making Neural Network. Science, 337, 437-444 (2012).

Please also see The Connectome Project website.

[2] Sulston, J.E., Schierenberg, E., White, J.G., and Thomson, J.N.   The Embryonic Cell Lineage of the Nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Developmental Biology, 100, 64-119 (1983).

[3] Jovelin, R., Dey, A., Cutter, A.D.   Fifteen Years of Evolutionary Genomics in Caenorhabditis elegans. eLS, doi:10.1002/9780470015902.a0022897 (2013).

[4] For a review of Caenorhabditis phylogeny and evolutionary biology, please see: Fitch, D.H.A. and Thomas, W.K.   Evolution. In "C. elegans II", Chapter 29. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Woods Hole, MA (1997).

[5] Gray, J.C. and Cutter, A.D.   Mainstreaming Caenorhabditis elegans in experimental evolution. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 281, 20133055 (2014).

[6] Danko, M.J., Kozlowski, J., Vaupel, J.W., and Baudisch, A.   Mutation Accumulation May Be a Minor Force in Shaping Life History Traits. PLoS One,  7(4), e34146 (2011).

[7] Thompson, O., Edgley, M., Strasbourger, P., Flibotte, S., Ewing, B., Adair, R., Au, V., Chaudhry, I., Fernando, L., Hutter, H., Kieffer, A., Lau, J., Lee, N., Miller, A., Raymant, G., Shen, B., Shendure, J., Taylor, J., Turner, E.H., Hillier, L.W., Moerman, D.G., and Waterston, R.H.   The million mutation project: a new approach to genetics in Caenorhabditis elegans. Genome Research, 23(10), 1749-1762 (2013).

[8] Schulte, R.D., Makus, C., Hasert, B., Michiels, N.K., and Schulenburg, H.   Multiple reciprocal adaptations and rapid genetic change upon experimental coevolution of an animal host and its microbial parasite. PNAS USA, 107, 7359 –7364 (2010).

[9] Degeneracy involves structurally different elements (such as functional neuronal networks) that converge upon the same output. An example of this within C. elegans: Trojanowski, N.F., Padovan-Merhar, O., Raizen, D.M. and Fang-Yen, C.   Neural and genetic degeneracy underlies Caenorhabditis elegans feeding behavior. Journal of Neurophysiology, 112, 951-961 (2014).

[10] Abouheif, E., Fave, M.J., Ibarraran-Viniegra, A.S., Lesoway, M.P., Rafiqi, A.M., and Rajakumar, R.   Eco-evo-devo: the time has come. Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology, 781, 107-125 (2014).

September 10, 2014

Upcoming DevoWorm talk to the OpenWorm group


This Friday (9/12) at 9am PDT, I will be presenting a talk to the OpenWorm consortium Journal Club on the DevoWorm project. For those of you who are unfamiliar, DevoWorm is a collaborative attempt to simulate and theoretically re-interpret C. elegans development.

Cover slide with a list of the DevoWorm collaborators, circa September 2014.

The structure of the talk will loosely follow the white paper, with some additional theoretical and translational information. We are also trying to organize/raise money for a "science hackathon", which would greatly improve the state of the project [1].


 An explanation of a scientific hackathon (sensu DevoWorm Collaboration).

The talk will also deal with the issue of whole-organism emulation. In this case, we are using a sparse representation of the organism to model developmental processes. The key is to balance tractability with biological realism. Sparko the Robotic Dog and the EPFL's Human Brain Project are used as examples.





We also discuss the potential usefulness of C. elegans emulations to biological problems. One problem we identified was the need to emulate and identify the precursors and mechanisms of phenotypic mutants. While our discussion of this will be limited to only a few slides, DevoWorm has the potential to model the possibility space of phenotypic mutants and perhaps even suggest developmental precursors to phenotypic mutations. 



If you are interested in attending, here is the Google Hangouts link. Look forward to a good presentation.

UPDATE 9/12:
The talk went very well. We also changed the name to "DevoWorm: raising the (Open)Worm". Lots of discussion about the potential for future collaboration and the regenerative capacity of C. elegans (or lack thereof). The talk was recorded to YouTube, and the link is here.



NOTES:
[1] Improvements largely involve physically bringing the group together, solving some problems related to data analysis, and perhaps even planning out additional data collection. Apparently, the term "hackathon" has a rather broad definition. But if you are interested in participating/helping to facilitate this, please contact me.

June 3, 2014

Now Announcing the DevoWorm Project


Over the past few months, myself and several colleagues (Stephen Larson, Dick Gordon, Steve McGrew, Mark Watts, and possibly Jack Tuszynski) have begun to hash out the details of a new project called DevoWorm. The project white paper, which lays out our goals and the associated technical details, can be found here. This is an extension of the existing OpenWorm project [1], which is an attempt to digitally emulate a relatively simple organism (C. elegans) from the cellular level up. In this case, emulation means a cell-by-cell representation and functional simulation in the spirit of open data movement.

Support the OpenWorm Kickstarter! Unfortunately, there is no DevoWorm Kickstarter (as of yet).

Whereas the OpenWorm project is focused on the C.elegans nervous system situated in an adult worm's body [2], DevoWorm will focus on C.elegans development and the process of cellular differentiation. C. elegans is the optimal candidate system to study this process on a cell-by-cell basis because every cell in every developmental lineage is known and labelled. In the late 1970s and early 1980s [3], a team of scientists lead by John E. Sulston [4] constructed a cell lineage tree which organizes the developmental process by both planar location [5] and number of cell divisions.


A set of modules on a cell lineage tree, courtesy Sulston et.al [3]. The depth is defined by not only a certain number of cell divisions (each branching event), but how many minutes the process of cellular differentiation takes (sampled at 50 minute intervals). In C. elegans, each module corresponds with a specific function or tissue.

C. elegans provides a computationally tractable model for this kind of work. This species of worm consists of 956 adult cells, of which 850 of these cells are unique. Fifty of these unique cell pairs are equivalent, allowing for 2- and 4-way symmetry. The nervous system is a popular model for connectomics research, as the entire nervous system consists of just 300 cells and several thousand connections between them. In addition, C. elegans cellular differentiation is enabled through a mechanism called juxtacrine signaling, which differs from the endocrine signaling mechanisms of more complex Metazoans. The result is that cell fate is determined by their absolute position rather than by their environmental context. This has not only allowed for the lineage of each cell to be traced, but for each cell to be invariant in its identity from worm to worm. This invariance allows us to create a "parts list" based on the nomenclature of each cell in the organism [6].

Moving from lineage tree to morphology: the case of C. elegans intestinal morphogenesis (from blastomere to daughter cell pairs cells to adult intestine). COURTESY: Figure 2 in [7].

One bit of functionality that distinguishes the DevoWorm project from previous attempts at understanding C. elegans development is the re-interpretation of the lineage tree as a differentiation tree. How does this aid in our understanding of the process? Differentiation trees are similar to lineage trees in structure, but requires one to follow the logic of hierarchical differentiation theory [8] and allows for embryogenesis to be conceived of as a series of contracting and expanding waves.

A differentiation wave occurs through coordinated action between cells. It is initiated by a cell that expands or contracts to send a signal to its neighboring cell. This signal is sent through a cytoskeletal element at the apical end of the cell, which is otherwise known as a cell state splitter. When binary cell differentiation occurs, this structure exists in a metastable state [8]. As cells change their shape and interact with the cell state splitter of their neighbors, a genetic regulatory program is activated in the receiving cell. This can induce changes within the receiving cell itself, or initiate the receiving cell to send information in the same way to the next neighbor downstream. As this process propagates from cell to cell, this can result in both expansion and contraction cascades, which can serve to specify the fate of entire tissues.

An example of how C.elegans can be reinterpreted as a differentiation tree. COURTESY: Dr. Richard Gordon.

In the differentiation wave model, each cell has a decision to make: whether or not to participate in an expansion or contraction wave. Depending on their size, we can measure this binary decision through indicators such as cell size. This gives us bits of information, which in turn gives us a differentiation code for a certain volume of cells or tissue. In a differentiation tree, the distribution and persistence of these waves define the modules of development. While we have not directly observed these processes in C. elegans, it has been observed in axolotl embryos [9]. In addition, the theory of hierarchical differentiation predicts that this mechanism actively guides C. elegans embryogenesis.

So this can essentially be thought of as a theoretical re-interpretation of the lineage tree concept, with application to whole-organism simulation. The ultimate goal of the DevoWorm project is to create a simulation of highly-specified organismal development, where virtual ablations and other perturbations can be introduced at various stages of development. The outcomes transcend a biological organism's ability to survive the treatment, and can give us important information about the plausibility of some phenotypes over others. At a future data, we would also like to characterize the functional genomics of C. elegans as a computational abstraction. This would provide us with even better resolution and allow us to ask more profound and fundamental questions regarding C. elegans embryogenesis.


UPDATE (7/15/2014): We have a new member of our group. I would like to welcome Tim Warrington, a graduate student who works on the genetics of C. elegans at Simon Fraser University.

UPDATE (10/14/2014): For more information on the origins of the OpenWorm project, please see: "A History and Pre-history of OpenWorm" (although it's more of a timeline).


NOTES:
[1] Palyanov, A., Khayrulin, S., Larson, S.D., and Dibert, A.   Towards a virtual C. elegans: A framework for simulation and visualization of the neuromuscular system in a 3D physical environment. In Silico Biology, 11(3-4), 137-147 (2012).

[2] For more on the project description and technical details, please see: OpenWorm. Artificial Brains: the quest to build sentient machines. August 14 (2012).

[3] The OpenWorm (and by extension DevoWorm) data structures are based on taxonomic work from the following papers:

a) Sulston, J.E. and Horvitz, H.R.   Post-embryonic cell lineages of the nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans. Developmental Biology, 56, 110-156 (1977).

b) Sulston, J.E., Albertson, D.G., and Thomson, J.N.   The Caenorhabditis elegans Male: postembryonic development of non-gonadal structures. Developmental Biology, 78, 542-576 (1980).

c) Sulston, J.E., Schierenberg, E., White, J.G., and Thomson, J.N.   The Embryonic Cell Lineage of the Nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Developmental Biology, 100, 64-119 (1983).

[4] Sulston, J.E.   C. elegans: the cell lineage and beyond. Nobel Lecture, December 8 (2002).

[5] Planar location is a location in a three-dimensional matrix: anterior-posterior (x), left-right (y), and dorsal-ventral (z).



[6] Sulston, J.E. and White, J.E.   C. elegans cell list. Worm Atlas (2014).

[7] McGhee, J.D.   The C. elegans Intestine. In "WormBook: Developmental Control", C. elegans Research Community (eds.), WormBook, doi/10.1895/wormbook.1.133.1 (2007).

[8] Gordon, R.   The Hierarchical Genome and Differentiation Waves: novel unification of development, genetics and evolution. World Scientific, London (1999).

[9] Gordon, R. and Bjorklund, N.K.   How to observe surface contraction waves on axolotl embryos. International Journal of Developmental Biology, 40, 913-914 (1996).

December 11, 2013

Speculating (and modeling speculation) about Biology, Culture, and Peer-review

Here are the latest features cross-posted to Tumbld Thoughts. A cornucopia of themes, from a model of pure speculation (I), to a new paper and reflections on the diversity of life-history strategies to aging across 46 species (II), and the human actions and reactionary tendencies that result from massive cultural change (III). Also featured is an update on biases inherent in the peer-review process (IV). So let's get started.

I. Pure (or Applied) Speculation


Here is an interesting model of predicting the future, courtesy of Anthony Dunne and Stuart Candy. In the book "Speculative Everything", Dunne and co-author present a design-centered vision for predicting the future [1].

Dunne's talk at the Resonante conference features a model of future prediction proposed by Stuart Candy of the Sceptical Futurist blog and LongNow foundation. Candy's model treats the future as a prismatic spectrum of future outcomes.


Using the prismatic spectrum metaphor (my coinage), the future is understood as an extension of the present, with progressively more and less likely outcomes. The "preferred futures" fall between the most likely and the most promising potentials.


II. What happens when you combine phylogeny, demography, meta-analysis, and life-history?

Apparently, yes it does.....

The top picture is from a new paper [2] that combines a phylogenetic perspective with demography (quasi-phylodemography) to look at variation in aging across the life-history of 46 species. A summary and set of insights from Phenomenon blog can be found in [3]. 

By compiling data from multiple sources and conducting a meta-analysis, the authors of [2] found that life history trends for fertility, mortality, and survivorship vary widely both cross-culturally (in humans) and across the tree of life. 


To make sense of this diversity, the authors of [2] propose a fast-slow continuum of senescence: from populations with a short-lived, early reproductive period to populations with a long-lived, extended reproductive period. These results can be compared with the review in [4], which presents the standard view of why we age, circa 2000.


III. The Action and Reaction of Cultural Change

Here is a rather long, detailed FAQ (some might say manifesto) from the Slate Star Codex on how to be an anti-reactionary. The detail is in the nature of Reactionism (or Neo-reactionism), which is the tendency to embrace the past (or zombie ideas) as if modernization will only bring degradation and "ruin everything" [5].


This notion of progress and reaction are largely based on human value systems, as Scott Alexander points out. While the reactionary would argue that turning away from traditional cultural value systems leads to economic ruin and rampant crime, the data show the opposite.


To get right to the point of this argument (so to speak), go to Section 3.3 (then where does progress come from). There you will find data from the World Values Survey, where the so-called "vanguard" countries (in terms of growth and safety) possess high levels of both secular-rational and self-expression values [6]. 



IV. Herding in peer-review

With significant apologies to Gary Larson and the scientific community. Please read on....

In the last Synthetic Daisies post, I featured a new paper of mine posted to the arXiv called "A Semi-supervised Peer Review System", which was itself based on a previous Synthetic Daisies post. In this paper, I introduced a model of automated objective manuscript evaluation focused on fraud detection. 


Now there is a new paper in Nature [7] that discusses the phenomenon of herding in peer-review and evaluation. Here, the authors use a Bayesian (as opposed to a signal detection) statistical model to describe what happens when reviewers converge upon a misclassification (e.g. rejecting a paper with solid conclusions and methods). They call for the inclusion of subjectivity in the decision-making criterion: subjective decisions are those that include assessing both the strength of a reviewer's agreement with the conclusions and more conventional features of the manuscript (e.g. strength of the premises and methods employed).



In the graphs above, two scenarios are compared: M1 (which is the subjective strategy) and M2 (which is a purely objective strategy). The authors claim that the M1 strategy prevents so-called herding and promotes a more unbiased outcome.

NOTES:

[1] the inability of people to envision novel and coherent futures is a prominent theme in "The Secret War between Downloading and Uploading" by Peter Lunenfeld. 

[2] Jones, O.R. et.al   Diversity of aging across the tree of life. Nature, doi:10.1038/nature12789 (2013).

[3] Hughes, V.   Why do we age: a 46-species comparison. Phenomena blog, December 8 (2013).

[4] Kirkwood, T.B.L. and Austad, S.N.   Why do we age? Nature 408, 233-238 (2000). Source of the bottom image.

[5] what that everything constitutes is not always clear. However, it could be the shock and uncertainty of the culture change process itself.

[6] similar to the argument Steven Pinker makes in "The Better Angels of our Nature", and for similar reasons.

[7] Park, I-U., Peacey, M.W., and Munafo, M.R.   Modelling the effects of subjective and objective decision-making in scientific peer review. Nature, doi:10.1038/nature12786 (2013) AND Dapper, A.   Should Scientists be more subjective? Nothing in Biology Makes Sense! blog, December 11 (2013).

February 25, 2012

Fictitious life-history.........


This is fun. I found this online somewhere.... For those who are unaware, Decapodia are a faux-extraterrestrial taxon from the TV show "Futurama" loosely based on the marine invertebrates of Earth. The life-history of Dr. Zoidberg, one of the main characters on the show, is illustrated (approximated?) from polyp to adult in the chart above. The "data" are taken from the episode "Teenage Mutant Leela's Hurdles" in which the entire cast quickly ages in reverse, causing them to re-live their life-history in reverse. While we might assume that Decapodian phylogeny capitulates ontogeny, those data are not shown.

Printfriendly